Can Governments Foster Innovation Without Stifling Growth?

Published
Feb. 5, 2025
Can Governments Foster Innovation Without Stifling Growth?
As the technology landscape continues to evolve, companies are caught in a tug-of-war of sorts as they try to find a balance between innovation and regulation. Governments across Canada and the U.S. are ramping up efforts to address concerns around AI, data privacy, and competition - all of which are there to protect consumers and ensure fair markets. But at what point does well-intentioned oversight become a barrier to progress?

For tech companies planning their next phase of growth, all these regulations require much more than simple checking compliance boxes - foresight and adaptability are key here. At Pender and Howe, we work with leadership teams who anticipate these shifts, not just react to them. 

Whether it’s AI governance, compliance costs, or competition laws, the key question remains: how can companies thrive when the rules are still being written?

AI regulations and ethical considerations

It seems like AI is already moving faster in 2025 than it did in all of last year, and that’s saying a lot. Regulators can barely keep up with this pace. 

In Canada, the Artificial Intelligence and Data Act (AIDA) is set to introduce new rules for AI governance, focusing on transparency, accountability, and ethical considerations. Meanwhile, the U.S. is in flux about how to regulate AI. A Biden law has since been rescinded, so the county must decide whether to regulate through broad federal oversight or state-by-state policies.

For companies using AI, these regulations could mean greater scrutiny of their models, stricter guidelines on bias mitigation, and increased reporting requirements. While the goal is to prevent harm and ensure fairness, heavy-handed oversight could slow down innovation, making it harder for companies - especially startups - to develop cutting-edge AI solutions without running into compliance roadblocks.

What this means for leadership

Tech leaders essentially have no choice but to build regulatory awareness into their AI strategies. That means developing internal policies now, rather than waiting for mandates to roll out. Companies that can demonstrate responsible AI usage early on will be better positioned when the rules inevitably tighten.

Data privacy and consumer protection

Privacy laws are evolving almost as fast as AI development. The U.S. is seeing a patchwork of regulations (many states have them), with California’s CCPA (California Consumer Privacy Act) leading the way, while Canada is working to modernize its own rules through the Consumer Privacy Protection Act (CPPA).

For companies handling vast amounts of consumer data (that probably applies to your company), the stakes are high. Missteps in compliance can lead to hefty fines, reputational damage, and even threaten data security posture. But beyond legal risks, there’s also the challenge of keeping consumer trust intact - especially as data breaches and privacy concerns make headlines on the regular.

What this means for leadership

Compliance needs to be perceived as beyond merely avoiding penalties and more of an opportunity to strengthen consumer confidence. Companies that take privacy seriously and prioritize transparency will always stand out in a business environment where trust is often as valuable as technology itself.

Big tech antitrust and competition

Regulators are turning up the heat on Big Tech. In the U.S., antitrust lawsuits against giants like Google and Amazon signal a growing effort to curb monopolistic behavior, while Canada is rethinking its own competition laws.

For smaller tech firms, these shifts could create new opportunities, especially if they actually lead to a more level playing field. But there’s also a risk that overly broad regulations could make it harder for mid-sized firms to scale, limiting the very competition that regulators aim to protect.

What this means for leadership

Growth-stage tech companies should keep a close eye on these legal battles. If regulators push for structural changes - such as breaking up monopolies or enforcing stricter market access rules - there could be new avenues for smaller players to compete. On the flip side, compliance with new laws could add an unwanted layer of complexity for emerging firms.

Innovation vs. compliance costs,     a startup dilemma

For large companies, compliance is just another line item in the budget. For startups and mid-sized firms, it can be a huge burden.

New regulations often come with significant costs - legal fees, compliance teams, security upgrades - which can weigh heavily on companies that are still in their growth phase. The challenge is staying ahead of these requirements without losing the agility that makes startups fun and competitive in the first place.

What this means for leadership

For growing companies, compliance planning just can’t be an afterthought anymore and must be part of a long-term strategy. By working regulatory-friendly processes into operations early, businesses can avoid costly course corrections down the road.

Cross-border tech policies

For tech firms operating across North America, regulatory fragmentation (not to mention the potential for tariffs) is a headache. While Canada and the U.S. share economic ties, their approaches to tech policy are not exactly aligned. The result? Companies face conflicting rules, differing compliance timelines, and extra complexity when expanding into new markets.

As governments try to harmonize policies - or, in some cases, move in opposite directions - tech leaders must stay ahead of these shifts to avoid regulatory surprises.

What this means for leadership

A cross-border mindset is no longer optional. Companies that keep regulatory differences in mind and incorporate them into their expansion strategies will have a much smoother path to scaling across North America.

The Pender and Howe bottom line

Regulation is inevitable. The challenge for tech leaders goes beyond simply following the rules and must be about shaping business strategies that allow for innovation despite them.

At Pender and Howe, we work with companies that are growing in a complex regulatory landscape. Our global and local expertise helps leadership teams identify individuals that support their organization in staying ahead of these changes and make informed decisions that drive both compliance and long-term success.

The key takeaway here is that regulations will evolve, but tech leaders who stay ahead of them will not only evolve but thrive.

Stay Ahead With the Latest Industry Insights

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter designed for busy execs, entrepreneurs, and aspiring leaders.

Subscribe

We value your privacy

By selecting “Accept all”, you give your consent to our use of cookies. These cookies and data are essential for the smooth functioning of our website. For detailed information about the cookies we use, their purposes, and our partners, please click “Manage cookies”. Here, you can also customize your preferences, and modify or withdraw your consent at any time. Learn more